NYC’s 31 Best Italian Sandwiches, Ranked

We're on a search to find the best Italian sandwiches in New York City. See the full ranked list and map on the Beli app.

Search status: Complete | Stops: 31

We’ve combed New York City in search of the best Italian sandwiches in NYC. From Alidoro to Faicco’s, we’ve tried them all so you don’t have to (you’re welcome).

See any you like? Save them on the Beli App—a (WAY) better version of that restaurant note/spreadsheet/map you’re using now. Click the button below to download on the App Store.

 
 
 
Regina's grocery Italian sandwich

#1 - Regina's Grocery

Beli rating: 9.0 | Chinatown

What to order: Uncle Jimmy

#2 - Lioni Italian Heroes

Beli rating: 8.8 | Bensonhurst

What to order: #139 Doo Wopper Hero

Emily's Pork Store Italian sandwich

#3 - Emily's Pork Store

Beli rating: 8.8 | Williamsburg

What to order: Italian Combo

casa della mozzarella sandwich

#4 - Casa Della Mozzarella

Beli rating: 8.8 | Little Italy (The Bronx)

What to order: The Casa (with Burrata)

Italian sandwich

#5 - Tony's Beechhurst

Beli rating: 8.7 | Whitestone

What to order: Tony’s Special

Benateri's Sandwich

#6 - Benateri's

Beli rating: 8.6 | College Point

What to order: Dante’s Inferno

#7 - Defonte's

Beli rating: 8.6 | Red Hook

What to order: Italian Combo

#8 - Mike's Arthur Avenue Deli

Beli rating: 8.6 | Little Italy (The Bronx)

What to order: Don Michele Hero

Leo's Latticini

#9 - Leo's Latticini

Beli rating: 8.6 | Queens

What to order: Super Italian

#10 - Royal Crown Bakery

Beli rating: 8.6 | Staten Island

What to order: Italian Hero

#11 - All'Antico Vinaio

Beli rating: 8.5 | Hell’s Kitchen

What to order: La Favolosa Sandwich, La Schiacciata del Boss Sandwich

Diso's Italian sandwich

#12 - DiSO's

Beli rating: 8.5 | MIdtown East

What to order: Joey Shakes Hero

Milano Market UWS

#13 - Milano Market Westside

Beli rating: 8.4 | Morningside Heights

What to order: Spicy Joey Sandwich, Milano Special (PICTURED)

#14 - Vintner Wine Market

Beli rating: 8.3 | Hell’s Kitchen

What to order: The Goodfella SandwicH

B&A Pork Store Sandwich

#15 - B&A Pork Store

Beli rating: 8.2 | Dyker Heights

What to order: Italian Deluxe

cappone's sandwich

#16 - Cappone's Italian Sandwich Shop and Salumeria

Beli rating: 8.2 | Chelsea

What to order: Cappone Sandwich

 
 
Faiccos Sandwich

#17 - Faicco’s

Beli rating: 8.2 | West Village

What to order: Italian Combo Hero

Varsi Deli Italian sandwich

#18 - Varsi Deli

Beli rating: 8.2 | Flushing

What to order: The Godfather

Anthony and Son Italian sandwich

#19 - Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe

Beli rating: 8.0 | Williamsburg

What to order: Godfather Hero

court street grocers Italian sandwich

#20 - Court Street Grocers

Beli rating: 8.0 | South Village

What to order: Italian Combo

la panineria Italian sandwich

#21 - La Panineria

Beli rating: 8.0 | Greenwich Village

What to order: Fresh Truffle Sandwich, Italian Sandwich

Milano Market UES Italian sandwich

#22 - Milano Market

Beli rating: 8.0 | Carnegie Hill

What to order: Amore Sandwich

#23 - Parisi

Beli rating: 8.0 | Nolita

What to order: The Dennis

Parm Italian sandwich

#24 - Parm

Beli rating: 8.0 | Nolita

What to order: Italian Combo Hero

#25 - Sergimmo Salumeria

Beli rating: 8.0 | Greenwich Village

What to order: Godfather Panini

Alidoro Italian Sandwich

#26 - Alidoro

Beli rating: 7.7 | South Village

What to order: Pinocchio Sandwich, THE GOTHAMIST (PICTURED)

#27 - Pisillo

Beli rating: 7.5 | Financial District

What to order: Pisillo Panini

sal kris and Charlie's Italian sandwich

#28 - Sal, Kris, & Charlie's

Beli rating: 7.4 | Astoria

What to order: THE BOMB, Italian Combo (PICTURED)

#29 - Alleva Dairy

Beli rating: 7.3 | Little Italy

What to order: Italian Sandwich

montagu's gusto Italian sandwich

#30 - Montagu's Gusto

Beli rating: 7.0 | Murray Hill

What to order: Frank Sinatra's Style Sandwich

#31 - Russo's

Beli rating: 7.0 | Ukrainian Village

What to order: Prosciutto and Soppressata Sandwich

See any you like? Save them on the Beli App—a (WAY) better version of that restaurant note/spreadsheet/map you’re using now. Click A button below to download On the App store or play store.